Search
What Happens When Three Siblings Inherit a New York City Townhouse?

What Happens When Three Siblings Inherit a New York City Townhouse?

One sibling wants to renovate, another wants to sell as is, and the third wants to stay in the home. What happens when all three inherit the same New York City townhouse?

In this week’s guest post, Rob Witherwax, a New York City attorney who practices real estate and trusts and estates law, walks us through why inheriting a home together can be more complicated than most families expect. If your family owns a home that may one day pass to several relatives, it’s worth talking openly about what each person hopes will happen to the property while everyone can still be part of the conversation.

— Julia Boland & Cathy Fuerth

Guest post by Rob Witherwax, Partner, Abrams Garfinkel Margolis Bergson, LLP

What Happens When Multiple Heirs Inherit?

There’s a classic New York story that plays out on every block in the city.  About 60 years ago, a young married couple scraped together a down payment, and bought a house.  They both worked good jobs at first – he’s in a union, she’s a teacher - but after the third child arrived, the wife left the work force and stayed home to raise them.  

The kids all went to local public schools, but then their paths diverge.  The oldest has a good income, starts a family, and buys an apartment in another borough, close enough to see Mom and Dad every few weeks, and able to help them out financially.  The middle child moves out of state, holds down a steady job, but doesn’t get back to NYC often at all – maybe once every couple of years.  The third child, the baby, never really left home.  

As time ticks by, and Mom and Dad get older, they pay off the mortgage, and they can carry the costs of taxes, insurance, utilities, etc. on their savings and pensions, but they don’t have a lot of money in the bank.  Yet property values have made them millionaires on paper.  A cousin who is a real estate agent tells them they could sell the house, and walk away with $3,000,000.

Of course, Mom and Dad don’t sell: where would they go? Their life is in the neighborhood, even as their friends age in place or move away or pass away, even as their local shops close and bars and restaurants reopen in their place, even as the neighborhood changes from single family homes to floor-through apartments or rooms to let and back to single family homes again.  

But inevitably, first Dad, and then Mom, pass away.  And now, perhaps even before the second funeral, the conversations about the house begin.  The real estate agent cousin gets three different phone calls: 

  • The oldest wants to take the time to renovate, and after a year or so, flip it.

  • The middle child wants to list right away and sell as is.

  • The youngest wants to stay at home and doesn’t want to sell at all.

In other words, there is absolutely no agreement.  Who gets their way?  Which path is chosen?  The answer to that depends on a few other unknown variables.

  1. How did Mom and Dad hold title?

Before the kids can decide on their options, they need to know what they actually own.  The starting point for that is the Deed. 


Husband and Wife

If the language on the Deed says that Mom and Dad held title as “husband and wife”, or “as a married couple” or “as tenants by the entirety”, then at Dad’s death, Mom owns the entire house by “operation of law”.  The kids can disregard Dad’s estate entirely.

Mom doesn’t have to do anything to the title after Dad dies: she doesn’t need to record a new deed, although some people do.  But she’s free to do whatever she wants with title – it’s her house, after all - and it’s worth checking to make sure that she hasn’t made changes to it.  

Sometimes, surviving spouses add other people on to title, either as a gift, or to put someone in ‘control’.  They might put the property into an entity – an LLC, or a Trust.  They could create a Life Estate, or a Transfer on Death deed.  All of this means that checking the state of title after Mom’s death is worthwhile.  

Tenants in Common

Alternately, Mom and Dad could have bought as tenants in common (or, similarly, they might not have been legally married).  Although less likely, in this circumstance, the kids would now need to look at Dad’s estate to determine where his interest went, before they turn to Mom’s, and see where hers went.  

If Dad had a Will, he probably gave his interest to Mom, but a Will is not enforceable unless it’s been admitted to probate.  Furthermore, he just as easily could have a Will that names the kids, or anyone at all, as beneficiary.  

And Dad could have NOT had a Will, in which event Mom inherited roughly half of Dad’s interest, and the kids shared the other half of Dad’s interest – as of the date of Dad’s death.

In summary, if Mom and Dad owned as husband and wife (or if they held it as tenants in common and Dad’s Will left his interest entirely to Mom), then Mom owns the entire house at her death.  

Mom’s Estate

Now the kids need to know if Mom had a Will.   If so, it needs to be admitted to Probate, and the kids have to follow any instructions concerning the house.  If Mom did NOT have a Will, then the three children share the house equally.

  1. Who is the fiduciary?

In this case, Dad and Mom owned as husband and wife, and Mom did not have a Will.  So Mom’s estate owns the entire house, and now needs to be administered by the Surrogates Court of the county where she resided.  To do that, a Fiduciary needs to be appointed.

Fiduciaries

There are two parallel proceedings in Surrogate’s Court to administer a decedent’s estate, Probate and Administration.  They are often confused and conflated with each other.  But whereas an estate with a Will goes through Probate and produces an Executor, an estate with no Will goes through Administration and produces Administrators.  The powers of Executor and Administrator are very similar, at the end of the process, but there are key differences in the way they are selected: 

  • The Executor is named by the decedent in their Will.  It could be anyone: it does not have to be a member of the decedent’s family.

  • The Administrator, on the other hand, is usually a relation.  Having no Will, the decedent missed the chance to make their preferences known.  So the law settles the matter by giving the decedent’s closest living relative “first crack” at being appointed.  

Here, Mom’s three kids are equidistantly related to Mom, and therefore each one has equal standing to be appointed as Administrator.  

Administrator(s)

So the first decision is, who will be Administrator?  A host of sibling dynamics can play out at this phase.  Some kids are “take charge”, some are “get along”, and usually those roles continue.  But long festering resentments and animosities can boil over here, too.

Each of the three kids has an equal right to be appointed.  The only factors that would disqualify someone from being appointed are age, lack of capacity, living in a foreign country, or being a convicted felon.  The law does not care that one child took care of Mom while the others lived elsewhere, or that one child is bad with money, or that one child is difficult to get along with.  

In practicality, not all children will want to serve.  The law gives them the option to ‘waive, renounce, and consent’: waive the necessity of service of legal process; renounce their co-equal right to serve; and consent to the appointment of one or more of their co-equals to serve.  

This is often a time to bargain, in large families.  Siblings who do want to serve campaign for support among the siblings who don’t.  Competing petitions are filed, the Court has to resolve them sometimes.  

With the three kids, the middle child, living out of state, agrees to waive and renounce.  Both the oldest and youngest, however, want to serve.  Provided both are not ineligible, the Court will appoint them as Co-Administrators.

  1. Settlement

After the Administrator is appointed, finally the kids can get down to business.  Title to property vested, on Mom’s death, in her three children, subject to the needs of estate administration.  So the Co-Administrators’ duties include marshalling the estate’s assets, and paying any debts or claims, and this may dictate the need to turn illiquid assets (like real property) into liquid ones.

Presuming there’s no need dictating a sale, the Co-Administrators have many options on the table, as long as they can agree which way to go.  

The first option is a sale:  If the Co-Administrators determine to sell the property, on the open market to a third party, they are free to do so.  It is easier to split cash than property.

Alternatively, one sibling could buy out the other two (or two could buy out the other one).  The sibling(s) getting cash would be entitled to appraisals to ensure the value was correct.

In either case, there would be minimal capital gains tax, due to the step up in basis.

If the Co-Administrators choose not to sell, they could come to a co-ownership arrangement.  They could deed it out of the estate, into the names of the three siblings, as tenants in common.  There would ideally be a management agreement in place, to govern the ins and outs of co-owning the property and protecting everyone’s interests.

Separate and aside from how they split title, the Co-Administrators could split occupancy: the house could have 1, 2, or 3 separate living spaces of varying sizes and amenities.  The siblings might own the house in equal shares, but use it inequitably.  Again, it’s workable, provided they agree, but where only one or two reside, there should be arrangements for fair market rent.

All of these take agreement and cooperation.  And here is where estates can get stuck for years.  The only mechanisms to resolve Co-Administrators’ differing opinions on what to do with estate property are settlement, mediation, or a court order.  Properties can sit for years in suspended animation, for better or for worse, because co-administrators cannot agree. 

Estate Sales 

If you are preparing to sell an inherited Manhattan co-op, condo, or townhouse, contact Julia Boland and Cathy Fuerth to request a copy of the Manhattan Estate Property Seller’s Guide and discuss a marketing plan for your property.

[email protected]

[email protected]

FAQs About Inheriting a New York City Townhouse

What should siblings do first when they inherit a townhouse?
Start by gathering the deed, any wills or trust documents, and a list of the property’s ongoing expenses. An estate attorney can help the family determine who inherited an interest in the home and who has authority to make decisions about it.

Can one sibling sell the townhouse if the others want to keep it?
Who can authorize a sale depends on how title is held and who has authority to act for the estate. If the siblings disagree, a buyout or mediation may help them reach an agreement. An estate attorney can explain what options are available if they remain at an impasse.

Can one sibling buy out the others?
A buyout can work if the siblings agree on the terms. An independent appraisal gives everyone a starting point for discussing what the property is worth. The family should also discuss how the buyout will be funded and when it can close.

What if one sibling already lives in the townhouse?
If the family is considering keeping the home, talk through who will live there, who will pay for taxes, insurance, and repairs, and whether the sibling in residence will pay rent. A written agreement can also spell out what happens if someone wants to sell later.

What should families talk about before anyone inherits the home?
Ask the owners what they hope will happen to the property. Then give everyone a chance to say whether they’d want to live there, keep it in the family, or sell. Talking openly while everyone can still participate gives the owners time to discuss those wishes with their estate attorney.

Is it worth renovating an inherited townhouse before selling?
Compare what the home could sell for as is with what it might sell for after renovations. Factor in the cost of the work, the time it will take, and the expenses of carrying the property in the meantime. A local real estate advisor can help the family evaluate both scenarios.

Work With Us

We’d love to hear from you! Whether you’re buying, selling, or just exploring your options, we're here to provide answers, insights, and the support you need. Contact us and start planning your next move.

Follow Us on Instagram